Cooley's Stone House Tavern

Great little restaurant and bar around the corner from the Hall of Fame. Awesome atmosphere and the food was really good. I got the cowboy burger with fries and it was cooked perfectly. Also overheard the bartender going through the list of wing sauces and those all sounded amazing. The staff were great and definitely made you want to come back.

Great spot, service and atmosphere. Stopped in for a quick lunch while in town. I ordered the grilled cheese. It wasn’t stellar. Other than that, had an enjoyable experience. I would order the Cowboy Burger or wings if I return.

Daeltun was our server and she was excellent. We had the grilled rueben and grilled chicken sandwich. Sandwiches were cooked perfectly and just delicious. We were very happy we took the recommendation from a worker at the MLB HOF to try Cooleys.

My friends and I were sitting in a booth and suddenly the booth collapsed from under us. We fell and it crushed the back of my friends leg. Her leg was stuck under the broken booth and she screamed in pain. It was so loud when the booth broke that everyone in the bar took notice, including staff. Not a SINGLE staff member checked in to see if any of us were okay. We were not offered any compensation or assistance. We know they noticed because a minute after we walked away from the booth they taped an “out of order” sign to the booth. A few minutes passed by I let the bartender know that I was shocked nobody checked in or offered us any assistance or compensation for what happened. I let them know that my friends leg was hurt and she was limping because of the pain. We were told to just go to the emergency room if there was a problem. This is some of the worst staff I’ve ever experienced. I cannot believe that an establishment would have such terrible manners and customer service. I’ve included pictures of the broken booth, the sign they hung up… as well as, a picture of my friends injured leg. Such a disgrace of an establishment. ALSO, to make matters worse, the staff gave US dirty looks and were whispering about US. The insanity. Also, the bartenders seem to not like to serve women. There was one guy in our group, and he was the ONLY one given decent service. The women in our group were ignored and given dirty looks.. Even though, we did nothing EXCEPT get hurt by this establishment!!!

Was up to visit the baseball HOF and stopped to check out this place for lunch. It was a nice old school place inside and out. The waitress was very helpful and good. Got a burger and the cowboy fritters and both tasted very good. The only downside I had was it seemed like the place was very dirty. I was sitting at the bar and there was fruit flies everywhere and just landing/sitting on the cups and in your way while eating your food. Was nice to try it but won’t be back.

When you first approach from the outside this place seems a bit like it was closed as you approach. Once inside it’s not a huge place but has that very old bar feeling to it. Our table was very wobbly so we grabbed bar seats. Drinks were made and as we were sitting there we noticed a ton of fruit flys which isn’t a good thing. But the food we ordered looked good. I ordered my burger well done and got cowboy fritters. The fritters were outstanding! The French fries I got with my burger were excellent as well. The burger was good up until I noticed that it wasn’t fully cooked I noticed a little pink inside. Which is fine for some. But a huge turn off on the food for me. Overall I’d give it a 4/5 stars the atmosphere was ok. For how old the place is I get the historical aspect of it.

Food is really good. It is worth the wait food is prepared to order. Definitely tastes fresh. I had their hot dog and chips. The chips are home made. Wife had the cheese burger sliders with fries they were great. If I am ever back in the area definitely stopping in. Thanks for the good eats.

Had the French Dip and a Chicken Caesar Salad. It was absolutely delicious! Every local football game on for Sunday at 1:00. Service was super fast and wonderfully friendly. Will absolutely be back.